M62

Who has (had) the greatest voice in Rock and Roll?

May 12 2014

I'm just talking about the voice here, not the song writing or recording success. Could it be the 'King', Elvis Presley? He was the greatest of the pioneers, certainly. Even the black singers of the day, who resented the likes of Bill Haley, were impressed by Elvis's talent.My personal favourite is Meatloaf, although his greatest hits, written by Jim Steinman in his unique Wagner-esque style doesn't appeal to everyone.Approaching universal appeal (though probably not appreciated by homophobes) would be Freddie Mercury. Whenever I watch 'Highlander', his version of 'New York, New York' (which Sinatra never allowed to be released as a recording) always sends chills through my spine.I think the ladies are best represented by Stevie Nicks (at least when allowing for international success). Her very individual sound and style ensured her longevity even without the rest of the Fleetwood Mac band members. Australia has some magnificent voices as well although my favourites only had limited international success. Jimmie Barnes is arguably our most successful domestic talent. Chrissie Amphlet's voice could make me wet my pants. Jon English has a powerful voice and a vocal range that is said to cover a five octave range and when you listen to 'Turn The Page', this seems realistic. Angry Anderson's performance of 'Born To Be Wild' is far more convincing than the original Steppenwolf version and of course, the man we call the 'Voice' is John Farnham.Do you reckon I've come close with any of these or would you vote for someone else?

Comments

RHP User

11 years ago

My vote goes to Robert Plant, who I was privileged to see at the Blues'n'Roots Festival 2013 in Fremantle.You can youtube that performance...do yourself a favour.

reply

like
madotara69

11 years ago

Is a little too close to home, much prefer to some banter at the table J man However it has been said that John Farnham, had the most versatile voice in the world. Mado Tara xx

reply

like
Mischeviouslad

11 years ago

It's a tie between Freddie and Prince.... if you can call prince R&R instead of pop - Posted from rhpmobile

reply

like
Twisted_Mister

11 years ago

Meatloaf, hands down. Although he's clearly down downhill in recent years, judging by his 'performance' at the AFL grand final...... - Posted from rhpmobile

reply

like
RHP User

11 years ago

Absolutely gotta be Janis I agree....xx Q

reply

like
RHP User

11 years ago

anyone you like. And the singer v the song(s). I think one of the greatest singers is Paul Rogers.And Otis Redding, (as a performer, too). Yup, Chris Cornell is a powerhouse.Hard to say with the gals, I like many, Linda Ronstadt, KD Lang ... I'm a musician, and I have a bit of a penchant for those who sing in tune. A lot don't. Especially live.But I still love Neil Young .... ;-)

reply

like
madotara69

11 years ago

not the best voice, but Joe Cocker gave it everything he had.

reply

like
RHP User

11 years ago

Quoting 'Jack_Denials' My vote goes to Robert Plant

reply

like
madotara69

11 years ago

Cindi Lauper Buddy Guy And when I was in the shower with Kylie Monogue the other night, she sung nicely

reply

like
RHP User

11 years ago

Imagine Dragons I actually dont know of most of the old timer music being discussed so far.... - Posted from rhpmobile

reply

like
RHP User

11 years ago

But OMG....Billie Holiday....Strange Fruit always makes me cry xx Q

reply

like
Paradisepair

11 years ago

Kurt - his voice moved millions and he literally gave it all he had. But I do love Robert Plant, for similar reasons...

reply

like
RHP User

11 years ago

Quoting 'Qefenta2' But OMG....Billie Holiday....Strange Fruit always makes me cry xx Q She just came on the radio no two ways about it a beautiful voice.

reply

like
RHP User

11 years ago

Jim Morrison would have to be a definite contender...along with Janis Joplin

reply

like

Who has (had) the greatest voice in Rock and Roll?

Comments

Tags

Boards

Forum help